Here is how we rated the individual performances on a memorable afternoon at Bramall Lane.
1. Chris Basham 8
Doubled up at every opportunity with Baldock to stop Zaha and did the job brilliantly. Defended brilliantly against dangerous Benteke in the air and got forward when he could, too Photo: Nathan Stirk
2. Jack O'Connell 8
Suffered an early blow to the head in an aerial challenge with Benteke but recovered well with another commanding performance. Unfortunate not to score from a header, from Basham's looping cross Photo: Shaun Botterill
3. Enda Stevens 8
Never stopped running all game and one moment of skill, with a superb pirouette to take him away from his marker, was a particular highlight. Looked a threat all game alongside Baldock Photo: Nathan Stirk
4. Oliver Norwood 8
Superb again, screening the back four and using the ball effortlessly and intelligently. One sprayed pass to Baldock completely foxed van Aanholt. A real captain's display in the middle of the park Photo: Shaun Botterill